Securities Commission Papers on Ethereum, XRP, and Other Cryptocurrencies Revealed by Coinbase
In the Loop:
Get the scoop on the latest crypto drama unfolding in New York! Back in 2023, the Attorney General's office made a bold move by seeking the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC's) opinion on Ethereum's status, hoping to bolster their case against KuCoin. However, the SEC declined to give a definitive answer.
A Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request by Coinbase unearthed this intriguing cat-and-mouse game between regulators. The emails shared between the SEC and various agencies reveal a behind-the-scenes uncertainty about how to regulate the cryptocurrency sector, despite aggressive legal action against these digital asset companies.
In a June 2023 email, Shamiso Maswoswe, the Investor Protection Bureau Chief in New York, approached the SEC asking if they considered Ethereum a security, or a commodity. Maswoswe argued that the SEC filing an amicus in support of the claim that Ether is a security would benefit investor protection.
The emails obtained by Coinbase highlight the SEC's private reluctance to clearly define their regulatory stance, even while pursuing enforcement actions against crypto firms. This inconsistency between regulatory clarity and enforcement actions is apparent in several of the federal agency's records, including correspondence with Ripple Labs about potential securities law violations in 2021.
In the letter to Ripple Labs dated December 9, 2021, the SEC expressed concern about the planned launch of Ripple's Liquidity Hub, fearing potential violations of federal securities laws involving XRP, Ripple's native cryptocurrency. Ripple, however, rejected the SEC's request for consultation about their business operations.
The recent revelations suggest that the regulatory landscape for digital assets remains uncertain, with ongoing debates about whether these assets should be treated as securities or commodities[1][2][3].
Tune-in Now:Stay tuned for more updates on the unfolding crypto drama. Subscribe to our Daily Debrief Newsletter for the latest breaking news in the crypto industry.
Based on information obtained from enrichment data and base article
[1] "What is Ethereum? Understanding its Security Status and Possible Regulation"[2] "SEC vs. Ripple: The Ongoing Legal Battle and Its Implications for the Cryptocurrency Industry"[3] "The SEC's Ambiguous Stance on Ethereum: Analyzing the Implications for Investors and the Market at Large"
- The SEC's response to the Attorney General's office regarding Ethereum's status in 2023 was not definitive, adding to the uncertainty around crypto regulation.
- Shamiso Maswoswe, the Investor Protection Bureau Chief in New York, inquired about the SEC's view on Ethereum's status as a security or a commodity in a June 2023 email.
- The SEC's private reluctance to clearly define their regulatory stance on cryptocurrencies is evident in their correspondence, such as the case with Ripple Labs and their concerns about XRP's potential securities law violations in 2021.
- The ongoing legal battle between the SEC and Ripple Labs highlights the complexities and debates surrounding the treatment of digital assets, like Ripple's native cryptocurrency XRP, as securities or commodities.
- The email exchange between the SEC and various agencies, obtained by Coinbase through a FOIA request, shows a lack of regulatory clarity even while enforcing actions against crypto firms, raising questions about the future of DeFi and crypto exchanges.
